Butterscotch and pumpkin? I didn’t think it could work either. But when Annie of the oh so fabulous Annie’s Eats pronounced these pumpkin cookies to be her favorites of all time, I took a leap of faith and tried them out (though honestly it was more like a tiny jump, since I love all the flavors).

Set your oven to 325F. After you grab all your ingredients, keep an eye out for sneaky kitties wandering around eying your treats

Then you mix two cups of flour

1 and 1/2 teaspoons of baking powder

1 teaspoon baking soda

1/2 teaspoon of salt

And a heaping teaspoon of ground cinnamon

A gentle whisking will mix everything up nicely, then you can set that bowl aside and grab another

In it you should put 1 cup of sugar

And two eggs!

Then, beat just these two ingredients until you have a smooth liquid that is very light

Just like this! Wonder Baker Tip: err on the side of using your bigger mixing bowls for wet ingredients because, more often than not, you’ll be adding your dry ingredients to the wet ones and not the other way around

Speaking of wet, it’s time to add 1 cup of pumpkin to your egg goo

Along with 1/2 a cup of vegetable oil

And a teaspoon of vanilla extract. Doesn’t the vanilla in the oil look really cool? I think so.

Blend that up until nicely combined

And then add your dry ingredient mixture. My bowl was big enough to add it all at once, but if you have a smaller bowl, add in halves or thirds

When that’s all combined, you’ll get a lovely orange dough that’s not too thick or sticky

Now, my sister is a little picky and doesn’t like butterscotch, so at this point I decided to separate out just a small amount of the cookie batter into another bowl and fold in some of my leftover mini chocolate chips from the pumpkin bread. That way she could still get some cookies and we’d have a different flavor on hand too.

If I had to venture a guess, I’d say that was a little less than a third of the batter overall. And I didn’t measure out the chocolate chips, I just dumped them in there until it looked right.

And the rest of the batter got just under a full cup of butterscotch chips folded right in.

To my sister’s delight, the chocolate batch ended up yielding nine whole cookies for her. I decided to set my timer for 12 minutes, though the recipe stated 14-16, because they seemed a little smaller than the ones in the recipe and it’s always good to check early.

Meanwhile I prepared a batch of butterscotch! For scooping, I just used a tablespoon measuring cup and plopped them onto the baking sheet using another spoon to scoop out. If you’ll notice, I didn’t have any parchment paper or silicone baking sheets, so I just lined my cookie pans with wax paper. It seemed to work out just fine.

After 12 minutes precisely, the chocolate chip cookies were finished. The toothpick came out clean and they looked amazing!

Just look at those bottoms! Set up perfectly with a little bit of browning on the edge, but the entire cookie is still fluffy and wonderful inside. I was extremely impressed with my choice of cooking time, if I do say so myself 🙂

I baked all my batches for 12 minutes and they all were perfectly done. Including this bonus batch which had butterscotch and chocolate chips in it! It was fun to just toss chips around into everything.

Oh wow, look at those! Now, one thing that was strange was the butterscotch chips didn’t seem to want to stay inside the cookie dough. They rolled out to the sides and even formed little craters as the cookie baked. The ones that were sticking out on the sides tended to stick to the wax paper, making it tricky to get the cookies off. So if you’re making these cookies, try to form them before you bake so that there aren’t any butterscotch chips sticking out on the sides. You can do this by just pushing them on top with a spoon or adding a little more of the dough to the edges around. It’s not a problem at all if they stick out, but this could make your life a little easier later

Hey, it’s the pumpkin bread I made earlier and a whole bunch of wonderful little cookies! I found that the pumpkin and the butterscotch worked great together, but the ones with both kinds of chips were probably my most favorite! Compared to the bread, the cookies are much fluffier and tend to get moist on the tops when you store them, but it’s not a soggy moisture so don’t worry about that. Pumpkin cookies are one of my favorite parts of fall and I hope you enjoy them too!

Check out the full recipe here at Annie’s Eats and have a  very happy eating!

2 Responses to “She blinded me with butterscotch (and pumpkin!)”

Leave a Reply